Shirley Grim gives year of birth as 1839.337

1860 Census, Beeler Station PO, Marshall Co., VA
Grim, Andrew, 23, farmer, personal estate value $75, b. PA
Nancy J., 16, b. PA

1870 Census, Liberty Dist., Marshall Co., WV
Grim, Andrew J., 34, farmer, real estate value $900, personal estate value $150, b. PA
Nancy J., 29, keeping house, b. PA
Thomas, 6, b. WV
Andrew J., 4, b. WV
Lucinda, 2, b. WV

1880 Census, Liberty, Marshall Co., WV
Grim, Andrew, 41, b. PA, parents b. PA, farmer
Nancy J., wife, 35, b. PA, parents b. PA, keeping house
Thomas, son, 16, b. WV
Andrew J., son, 14, b. WV
Lucinda, dau., 12, b. WV
Mary B., dau., 9, b. WV
Harvy, son, 8, b. WV
Huldy, dau., 5, b. WV
Isaac N., son, 3, b. WV
Benjamin, son, 7 months, b. WV

1900 Census, Spring Creek Dist., Wirt Co., WV
Grim, Andrew J., b. March 1836, 64, m. 36 years, b. PA, parents b. PA, farmer
Nancy J., wife, b. Jan. 1844, 56, m. 36 years, 12 children/9 survive, b. PA, parents b. PA
Phebe, dau., b. March 1881, 19, b. WV
James, son, b. May 1883, 17, b. WV, farm laborer